Apr 112014

seaworldscreenshot-googlenewsSea World has lost its appeal of an OSHA fine for exposing a trainer — who died working with a killer whale — to dangerous working conditions (SeaWorld v. Perez, 12-1375, D.C. Cir., 4/11/14).

The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a $7,000 fine imposed after Dawn Brancheau was drowned by a killer whale in Orlando in February 2010, a little more than four years ago.

OSHA had proposed a $70,000 penalty, but an Administrative Law Judge reduced it by $63,000 after concluding that SeaWorld’s violations were not “willful.”

The ruling was 2-1, with Circuit Judge Brett Kavanaugh dissenting. He said lots of sports are dangerous, yet attract wiling participants.

“The broad question implicated by this case is this: When should we as a society paternalistically decide that the participants in these sports and entertainment activities must be protected from themselves — that the risk of significant physical injury is simply too great even for eager and willing participants? And most importantly for this case, who decides that the risk to participants is too high?”

But the two judges in the majority — Judith Rogers and Merrick Garland — upheld the ALJ’s findings.

“The record evidence showed that SeaWorld’s training and protocols did not prevent continued incidents, including the submerging and biting of one trainer in 2006, the killing of a trainer by a SeaWorld-trained and -owned killer whale in 2009 at an amusement park in Spain, and Ms. Brancheau’s death in 2010. SeaWorld employees repeatedly acknowledged the unpredictability of its killer whales. This record evidence supports the ALJ’s finding that existing protocols were inadequate to eliminate or materially reduce the hazard to SeaWorld’s trainer employees performing with killer whales.”

Brancheau “was interacting with Tilikum, a killer whale, during a performance before a live audience in a pool at Shamu Stadium in Orlando,” the court explained. “[She] was reclined on her back on a platform a few inches below the water surface. Tilikum was supposed to mimic her behavior by rolling over. Instead, the killer whale grabbed her and pulled her off the platform into the pool, refusing to release her. She suffered traumatic injuries and drowned as a result of Tilikum’s actions.”

Said the court:

Ms. Brancheau’s death demonstrated that close contact with killer whales was a hazard likely to cause death or serious injury. Based on evidence regarding three previous deaths involving killer whales (beginning in 1991 with Tilikum), SeaWorld’s written training manuals and safety lectures as implemented specifically to Tilikum, and SeaWorld’s incident reports, the [Administrative Law Judge] found that the Secretary had established by “abundant” record evidence that “SeaWorld recognized the hazard created when its trainers worked in close contact with Tilikum during drywork performances,” satisfying the second element of a violation. Id. at 25-26, *19. Further, the ALJ found that evidence, including SeaWorld’s incident reports, established that SeaWorld recognized the hazard when trainers worked in close contact with other killer whales; SeaWorld’s statistics regarding the predictability of killer whale behavior, on the other hand, were unpersuasive because not based on rigorous, scientific data. The ALJ concluded that SeaWorld’s claim that “it was unaware working with killer whales presents a recognized hazard is difficult to reconcile with numerous comments made over the years by SeaWorld management personnel, including [two] corporate curators of animal training . . . [whose] comments were documented and circulated among all of the SeaWorld parks.” Id. at 29, *22.

The court said SeaWorld has already changed its practices.

The remedy imposed for SeaWorld’s violations does not change the essential nature of its business. There will still be human interactions and performances with killer whales; the remedy will simply require that they continue with increased safety measures. SeaWorld itself has limited human interactions. After Ms. Brancheau’s death in 2010, SeaWorld ceased “waterwork” with all of its killer whales. It also imposed distance between trainers and Tilikum during drywork and, to a lesser degree, between other killer whales and trainers during

Apr 032014

Four conservation groups say the Bureau of Land Management has been shirking its responsibility to provide annual reports to the Fish and Wildlife Service Center on the health of at-risk species in California deserts. The Center for Biological Diversity, Sierra Club, Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility and Desert Survivors filed two notices of intent to [...]

Apr 032014

The Fish and Wildlife Service has failed to make the required 12-month finding on a petition to list the black-backed woodpecker as a threatened or endangered species in two regions – California/Oregon and the Black Hills of South Dakota/Wyoming, the Center for Biological Diversity said in a notice of intent to sue. In a press release, [...]

Apr 032014
Listing sought for San Berdoo squirrel

The Center for Biological Diversity has filed a notice of intent to sue the Fish and Wildlife Service to compel a decision on the San Bernardino flying squirrel. In a press release, CBD said the “rare, truffle-eating flying squirrel is threatened by climate change, forest habitat destruction, and predation by domestic cats, and has disappeared [...]

Apr 012014

Rep. Doc Hasting (R-Wash.) has weighed in on District Judge Emmet Sullivan’s decision upholding two multispecies settlements committing the Fish and Wildlife Service to make decisions on 757 species. The chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee said the decision “upholds the Administration’s mega-settlement with litigious environmental groups to make listing decisions for hundreds of [...]

Mar 252014

Links being updated (3/25/14, 1:30 pm) Coverage on the Web Gina McCarthy’s prepared remarks for 3/25/14 press call Audio file (MP3) of teleconference (about 30 minutes) American Rivers Earthjustice American Farm Bureau (3/17/14) Natl. Association of Home Builders EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers have released a proposed rule to clarify the extent of [...]

Mar 142014
FWS needs to do more on Cape Wind project, judge rules<h3>But Walton also finds for feds in challenges to Mass. wind energy project</h3>

The Fish and Wildlife Service needs to make its own determination on the effects of Cape Wind on roseate terns and piping plovers, a federal judge ruled today in a multi-pronged challenge to the high-profile wind energy project off Nantucket (Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility v. Beaudreau, 10-1067 RBW, D.D.C.). Both sides claimed victory after [...]

Mar 132014

The Ninth Circuit has reversed U.S. District Judge Oliver Wanger, finding that the Fish and Wildlife Service’s 2008 delta smelt Biological Opinion was not arbitrary and capricious (San Luis and Delta-Mendota Water Authority v. Jewell, 11-15871). (Opinion from ESWR website) Below is the court’s summary of its decision, issued today (March 13). The summary was [...]

DOI releases proposed FY 2015 budget

 Posted by on March 4, 2014
Mar 042014

Posted March 7: Audio and transcript of the teleconference with Interior Secretary Sally Jewell Go here for department’s web site for its proposed FY 2015 budget. Go here for the entire Budget in Brief document. Bureau Highlights Bureau Highlights Bureau of Land Management Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement Office [...]

Feb 282014

EPA has begun a 404(c) review process of the proposed Pebble Mine under the Clean Water Act, and until it’s completed,  the Army Corps of Engineers “cannot issue a permit for fill in wetlands or streams associated with mining the Pebble deposit,” EPA said in a press release posted today. “This is a unique mine in [...]